The Heartbreaking Disappearance of Brittney Ann Beers: A Young Life Lost to the Shadows of Sturgis
The evening of September 16, 1997, started like any other for six-year-old Brittney Ann Beers in the small town of Sturgis, Michigan. The blonde, blue-eyed girl with the infectious smile had no way of knowing that when she stepped outside her family's apartment at Village Manor Apartments to ride her bicycle, she would become the center of one of Michigan's most enduring missing person cases. More than two decades later, her disappearance continues to haunt investigators, her family, and the community of Sturgis.
A Day That Changed Everything
Brittney went outside to ride her bicycle at approximately 7:30 p.m., excited to spend time outdoors on what was a pleasant September evening. Her mother, Tina Stetler, left to run errands at approximately 8:30 p.m. and saw her daughter riding her bicycle around the neighborhood at that time. It would be the last time Tina would see her youngest daughter alive.
Brittney was 6 years old, approximately 4 feet tall and 45 pounds when she went missing. She was a Caucasian female with blonde hair and blue eyes, and was missing her four upper baby teeth at the time of her disappearance in 1997. She was last seen wearing a white tank top or t-shirt with a floral design, pink tie-dyed shorts and white sneakers with a pink design on the sides. Her shoelaces had a red stripe down the center.
The timeline of that fateful evening has been reconstructed through witness statements and family accounts. Brittney's half-brother told authorities he saw his sister sitting on a bench about five minutes after their mother departed. What happened next would become the most crucial and haunting detail of the entire case.
The Mysterious Stranger
A witness told investigators that he saw Brittney speaking to an unidentified male driving a red or brown mid-size vehicle shortly thereafter. Even more concerning, Brittney walked over to the witness and told him that she "made a new friend." This detail becomes particularly significant when considering what those who knew Brittney best said about her personality. According to Morbidology, Beers' older half-sister, Dixie, would later say that the 6-year-old girl was "so scared and skittish about talking to strangers."
The man was described as being in his late twenties or early thirties with short dark hair and a thick mustache and was driving either a mid-sized red car or a brown Renault. Sketches of the unidentified man seen speaking to Brittney were distributed through the area in the days following her disappearance. Despite extensive distribution of these composite sketches, the man was never identified.
When Stetler returned home at approximately 9:05 p.m., she asked Brittney's brother to find her. The authorities were summoned when the child could not be located near the apartment complex, which is located on U.S. 12, the major thoroughfare through Sturgis. Brittney's bicycle was discovered abandoned shortly after she was last seen.
The Search and Investigation
As one member of the search party, Geoff Smith, Sturgis director of public safety, told The Sturgis Journal in 2017: "That first night was about 20 hours long. We slept for about four hours and we were back at it. It was like that for a couple weeks."
An unfortunate reality of the situation was that the apartment complex was along U.S. Highway 12 which was the main road through Sturgis. This meant that it would be relatively easy for someone to make a quick escape out of town.
A bloodhound was able to follow Brittney's scent from her apartment to a nearby Marathon gas station, where the trail ended. This detail suggested that Brittney had likely been taken from the area by vehicle, supporting the witness account of her speaking to a man in a car.
According to Morbidology, an early focus for investigators was a nearby area that encompassed 40 acres and included open fields in addition to railroad tracks and storage buildings, but there was no sign of Beers. "There's certainly a potential for an abduction," one investigator told the Battle Creek Enquirer in 1997. "It's pretty reasonable to think that there's something more than her just having wandered off or run away."
A Troubled Home Life Exposed
As the investigation deepened, disturbing details about Brittney's home life began to emerge. The 6-year-old lived with her mother, Tina Stetler and her uncle, James Allen Beers, in Village Manor Apartments in Sturgis, Michigan. She attended Fawn River School and loved art and playing outside. One picture that made her particularly proud was an arrangement she had made from oak leaves pasted on paper.
However, neighbors had observed troubling signs. Rumors about the family started to circulate through the streets and neighbors spoke of neglect and abuse in the household. Several people noted that Brittney was often spotted playing outside on her own and once told a neighbor that her mother would lock her out of the house if she was bad.
A neighbor, Gale Ashbrook, often saw Brittney playing alone in a sandbox near her own apartment. She would tell Brittney to go home because the sandbox was quite far from where she lived and she shouldn't have been out there alone.
The situation became even more tragic when the full extent of abuse in Brittney's life was revealed. At just 3-years-old, Brittney was sexually abused by Kevin Folsom. Her abuse came to light when she refused to let her babysitter bathe her one evening. When the babysitter questioned her, Brittney told her that Folsom had been molesting her.
In an August 1995 interview, Folsom told police that he had become aroused while bathing the toddler and started to touch her. Folsom was imprisoned for molesting Brittney, but he was released in 2008.
Family Removal and Court Proceedings
The abuse revelations led to significant legal action. Months after Brittney's disappearance in January of 1998, her older brother, Joshua Lee Folsom and younger sister, Autumn Stetler, were both removed from the home due to alleged child abuse by James Allen Beers. Tina was urged to leave him due to the abuse he put her children through but she refused and as a result they were taken from her care.
Michigan courts removed Brittney's older brother and younger sister from the family's home in 1998 after allegations of child physical and sexual abuse and neglect were issued. Brittney's father, Raymond Beers; his brother, James Beers; and Kevin Folsom, the father of one of her half-brothers, were allegedly involved in the abuse of the children.
A judge was quoted as saying: "I'm not going to return the children to her with James Beers around, knowing her son is afraid of him, knowing what he's done to other children."
The following year, Stetler had a termination petition hearing in which she volunteered to give up her parental rights. She admitted that she just didn't have accommodation or finance to take care of her two remaining children. Brittney had been removed from the petition as she still remained missing. "If she is found, a separate petition will be formed for that case," said Probate Court Judge Thomas Shumaker.
A Person of Interest Emerges
For years, investigators followed countless leads without significant breakthroughs. However, in 2015, a potential breakthrough emerged when police named Daniel Furlong as a person of interest in Brittney's abduction. He abducted, sexually assaulted and strangled an eleven-year-old girl, Jodi Parrack, in 2007.
The murder was not solved until 2015, after Furlong abducted a ten-year-old girl who subsequently escaped from him. After he became a suspect in the child's abduction, he provided a DNA sample which linked him to Jodi's murder. He subsequently confessed to the murder, pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison.
What made Furlong particularly interesting to investigators in Brittney's case were several striking similarities. Furlong bears a striking resemblance to the sketch of the man seen with Brittney prior to her disappearance, his known crimes were similar to Brittney's disappearance, and Jodi closely resembled her. Constantine Township is only 16 miles and 23 minutes away from Sturgis where Brittney disappeared from.
As part of Furlong's plea deal, he was interrogated by Michigan State Police detectives and others about the Parrack and Beers' case. In the hours-long interrogation, Furlong said he did not kill Beers. "I'm not sure if he can tell the truth about anything let alone if he was guilty of something," said Smith. "It's back to gut feeling."
Smith described Furlong's demeanor as "cold" and "un-remorseful" as he confessed to the gruesome details of Parrack's murder, while eating pizza and drinking coffee. He has maintained his innocence in her case, but remains one of the few persons of interest.
The Search for Answers Continues
Over the years, police investigated over a thousand leads. Age progression images of Brittney were released every once in a while in the hopes that somebody somewhere knew something and would come forward. Police have received tips, about 1,100 so far, and they still follow up on every one of them.
Brittney's case received more publicity in 2000 after the arrest of a St. Clair Shores, Michigan man who had images of child sexual abuse saved on his computer. One of the victims resembled Brittney, but was later determined not to be the missing girl.
The case has maintained visibility through various media efforts. Missing person posters with Brittney's face on the front were plastered to the back of 500 Zeller Bach Trucking semi trailers while another 200 were displayed on NASCAR and Hot Rod Association vehicles.
A Community's Enduring Hope
Despite the passage of time, Brittney's case remains active. Every year, to mark Brittney's disappearance, a group of people would gather at the Village Manor Apartments where Brittney was last spotted. The bench where she was last seen is now long gone but the memories still remain. Ruth Ann Beers and her husband, James, who lived in Corpus Cristi, Texas, made the trip most years to commemorate Brittney.
"My gut tells me that she is probably not alive. I hope she is," says Detective Sergeant Geoff Smith of the Sturgis Police Department. "But like it said, this many years out it is hard to keep up that hope."
Brittney's old neighbor, Frohriep, keeps hoping. She planted flowers in memory of Brittney, and like the rest of the community here in Sturgis, "I'll never forget her."
The Lasting Impact
Brittney's story serves as a tragic reminder of the vulnerability of children and the devastating impact of domestic violence and abuse on families. Her case highlights how neglect and abuse can create dangerous situations for children, making them more susceptible to predators. The fact that a child described as "scared and skittish about talking to strangers" was seen speaking to an unknown man suggests either coercion or that something about the interaction made her feel safe enough to engage.
Brittney's case remains open and unsolved. Brittney's abduction remains unsolved. The investigation continues under the Sturgis Police Department and the FBI, with authorities still hoping that someone will come forward with information that could finally bring answers to what happened to Brittney Ann Beers on that September evening in 1997.
Anyone with information on Brittney Ann Beers' disappearance is asked to contact the Sturgis Police Department at 269-651-3231.
The case of Brittney Ann Beers reminds us that behind every missing person statistic is a real child who had dreams, fears, talents, and people who loved them. Brittney was proud of her art projects, loved playing outside, and deserved to grow up safe and protected. Her story continues to touch hearts and serves as motivation for continued efforts to protect vulnerable children and to never give up hope in bringing missing children home.
Sources
-
The Resource Center For Cold Case Missing Children's Cases - Brittney Ann Beers
-
WBCK FM - Cold Case Sturgis: The Disappearance Of Brittney Beers
